Who Owns the Web Now?

ReflectionMonday, November 16, 2026·7 min read

The open web is being squeezed from two sides. Publishers are losing readers, because Google now answers questions on its own results page and fewer people click through to the sites that wrote the answers. Users are losing control, because their personal data has been gathered…

Who Owns the Web Now?

Solid, Google Zero, and the fight over whom the next layer of the internet works for

Date: 16 November 2026

• • •

The open web is being squeezed from two sides. Publishers are losing readers, because Google now answers questions on its own results page and fewer people click through to the sites that wrote the answers. Users are losing control, because their personal data has been gathered into a handful of corporate silos.

The two problems look different, but they share a root. Value that once flowed across an open network is now captured by whoever sits in the middle. This article looks at both: Google Zero, the drying-up of search traffic, and Solid, Sir Tim Berners-Lee's long-running effort to give people back control of their data. It then looks at where the two meet, in the race to build AI agents.

• • •

Google Zero: when search stops sending readers

"Google Zero" is the name publishers give to a future in which Google sends them almost no traffic. The term was coined by Nilay Patel, editor of The Verge. The main cause is AI Overviews, the AI-written summaries placed above the ordinary search results. They answer the question on the spot, so the reader has little reason to click.

The reported figures so far:

MeasureReported figure
Traffic loss for a top-ranked page when an AI summary appears above it (Authoritas)Up to 79%
Fall in organic click-through rate on queries that show AI Overviews (Seer Interactive)61%
Change in search referrals, small publishers (1,000–10,000 daily views)−60%
Change in search referrals, mid-sized publishers−47%
Change in search referrals, large publishers−22%
The Verge, organic search visits, February 2024 to January 20265.3 million to 0.79 million
Share of publisher traffic referred by all AI platforms combinedAbout 1%

Small and general-interest sites are hit hardest. How-to guides and definitions suffer most, because a model can rewrite them easily. Referrals from AI chatbots are growing, but from a base far too small to make up the loss.

WARNING: Publishers cannot simply opt out. As Klaudia Jaźwińska of Columbia University's Tow Center puts it, leaving AI Overviews means you "opt out of Google Search entirely." That is why the dispute is now being fought under competition law rather than over technical settings.

Regulators have begun to move. A coalition led by the Independent Publishers Alliance has filed an antitrust complaint with the European Commission. The UK's Competition and Markets Authority has said Google should give publishers clear metrics when their content is used in AI Overviews and AI Mode.

The size of the damage is disputed. Google says the traffic claims rest on incomplete and skewed data. The Daily Mail's head of SEO has said the overall effect on that site has been milder than feared, and some analysts argue that blaming AI Overviews alone oversimplifies a decline with several causes. The direction, though, is not in doubt: search is turning from a referral engine into an answer engine.

• • •

Solid: putting data back in the user's hands

Solid, short for Social Linked Data, is a project to decentralise the web, led by Berners-Lee and first developed at MIT. Its central idea is simple:

  • Each person keeps their data in a Pod, a personal online data store that they control.
  • Apps and services ask permission to read from or write to the Pod, instead of copying the data onto their own servers.
  • The data stays with the person when they switch providers. They change the app, not the data.

In 2018 Berners-Lee and John Bruce launched Inrupt to take Solid to market. In October 2024 stewardship of the Solid standard passed to the Open Data Institute, a non-profit Berners-Lee co-founded in 2012, while Inrupt concentrated on enterprise infrastructure built on top of it.

Berners-Lee has never presented Solid as something Big Tech must approve. Asked whether Facebook and Google would go along with it, he answered: "We are not asking their permission."

NOTE: Solid works at the level of data, not content. It governs who may read and write your personal information, such as your calendar, health records and preferences. It does not decide who gets paid when an article is read.

• • •

Where they meet: the agent layer

The two stories meet in AI agents.

Google Zero is what happens when an AI stands between the reader and the web and works for the platform. Solid's newest chapter is an attempt to build the opposite: an AI that stands between you and the web and works for you.

That agent is called Charlie. Berners-Lee set out the idea in his January 2025 essay "Charlie Works", and Inrupt has since built a working prototype. Charlie draws on the personal data in your Pod to tailor its answers, asks for explicit consent, and masks personal details before anything is sent to a large language model. Berners-Lee likens it to professions that already owe their clients a duty of care: Charlie "works for you like your doctor or your lawyer."

His 2025 memoir, This Is for Everyone, makes the same case at book length. There is still time, he argues, to build machines that serve people rather than extract from them.

KEY POINT: For a publisher, a university or a company, the question is no longer whether AI will sit between you and your audience. It will. The question is whose interests that layer serves, and who controls the data it runs on.

• • •

What Solid can't fix

Solid is a serious answer to half the problem. It is not a cure for both halves.

  • It does not bring back publisher traffic. A reader whose data lives in a Pod can still take the answer from an AI Overview and never visit the source.
  • Adoption is the bottleneck. People say they want control of their data; few want the work of managing it. A BBC executive involved in Solid trials made exactly this point.
  • Hosting is unsolved. Someone has to run the Pods and the agents. If a few large providers end up hosting most of them, the old centralisation returns in a new form.

Solid's strongest feature is that it is an open standard, not a product. Like the original web, its value depends on many independent parties choosing to build on it.

• • •

What this means in practice

For organisations in Malaysia, whether newsrooms, universities or technology firms, four lessons follow.

  1. Own the relationship, not just the ranking. Newsletters, apps, communities and events cannot be swallowed by an AI summary. The publishers holding steady are those with a direct, loyal audience.
  2. Publish what a model cannot easily rebuild. Original data, field reporting, expert judgement and local context keep their value. Generic explainers do not.
  3. Design for agents that ask permission. Any system holding user data, such as student records, client portals or IoT dashboards, should expect AI agents to request access. Build consent and scoped access in from the start, in the spirit of Solid.
  4. Treat data sovereignty as a design decision. Where data lives, and who may read it, is part of the architecture, not a compliance question to settle later.

The web was given away on the principle that it should belong to everyone. Google Zero shows what happens when the layer above it belongs to one party. Solid is a bet that the next layer can still be built the other way.

• • •

Prepared by TXIO Fusion Solutions

Disclaimer: This article is prepared for awareness and discussion. Figures are as reported by the sources below, several of which are disputed, and are not independently verified. It is not legal, business or investment advice.

Sources

The Verge, origin and tracking of the "Google Zero" concept

eWeek, "'Google Zero' Looms as AI Search Results Crush Publishers' Traffic" (Authoritas figures; EU antitrust complaint)

Editor & Publisher, "Approaching Google Zero" (The Verge traffic figures)

DesignRush, publisher search referral changes by size

Everything PR, Seer Interactive click-through data; AI referral share; Jaźwińska quote

Press Gazette, CMA position; Daily Mail SEO view

The Media Roundup, critique of the AI Overviews explanation

Wikipedia, "Solid (web decentralization project)"

Fast Company, Inrupt and the October 2024 handover of Solid to the Open Data Institute

The Blaze (reporting Fast Company, 2018), Berners-Lee on not asking Big Tech's permission

Open Data Institute, Solid project page

TBS News / The New Yorker, Charlie and the BBC adoption remark

WebProNews, Charlie's consent and data-masking design

Newser / The New Yorker, This Is for Everyone

W3C Design Issues, Tim Berners-Lee, "Charlie Works" (January 2025)